WPI Worcester Polytechnic Institute

Computer Science Department
------------------------------------------

CS 3043 - Social Implications of Information Processing - C12

* * * Under Gradual Construction * * *

Version: January 5 2012

Class Hours

 Monday & Thursday, 8:00-9:50 a.m., Salisbury Labs, SL011.


Class Mailing List

Information about running the course will be disseminated by email using the class mailing list. If you join after the beginning term, it is your responsibility to subscribe to it, through the link below.

The course has a MyWpi site, though I currently expect a limited use for it, principally the discussion boards for your convenience in off-class discussions. Use it as a course-wiki.

Mail sent to  cs3043-staff at cs dot wpi dot edu  will go to the professor and the TA.
Please contact us this way, unless the content is personal.

Note that you can subscribe or unsubscribe yourself to the class mailing list "cs3043".

Teaching Staff

Instructor:   Micha Hofri   <hofri at wpi . edu>
Office: Fuller Labs, room 133, Phone: 508-831-6911
Office Hours: Mon & Wed. 4:00--5:00pm, or email for appointment.

Teaching Assistant:   Can Tatar   < can at wpi . edu>
Office: FL317.
Office hours: Mon & Thursday 10--11am, or email for appointment.

Textbook

  • Required text:


    The bookstore has the text, and there is a copy on reserve in the library for emergencies. While we expect to touch on many of the topics it considers, there is clearly much more in the book than we can handle during one term.

  • Additional background:


    This is a fairly recent book by noted computer scientists. The library has a copy; in addition you can read it online, via the library site, since it is an open Google Book.



  • An older book, that includes many good expositions of topics we discuss in the course, and several extended case reports. I put a copy on reserve in the library.

  • The course schedule shows for some of the meetings pointers to readings that are particularly relevant to the topic of the meeting.
  • Notes:
    As the course progresses, Class Notes will be posted as links in the schedule on the course web page below.
  • Glossary: The Glossary from the text book is available for use in this class.

Course Objectives

We will study and discuss the issues involved in the proliferation of computers embedded in our lives and the world around us. The course will:
  • Raise our awareness of the effects of computers and information technology on our society, its values, our institutions;
  • Provide opportunities to reflect on the responsibility of a computer professional to society and to the profession;
  • Inform us about the controversial issues concerning integrating computers into our lives, as well as the different points of view about these issues;
  • Provide us with the tools, and skills, needed to develop a point of view on the issues raised in the course, to form a personal opinion based on well-thought out arguments, and to present effectively our positions.
  • Provide opportunities to develop critical reading and writing skills.

Course Methodology

To achieve these objectives, you will:
  • Read the assigned sections from the text,
  • Participate in class discussions,
  • write several homework papers,
  • Critique and evaluate papers of your peers.

    While we view all four methods as important, especially for the discussion, it is imperative that you attend class regularly and stay up to date on readings and assignments.

    A short time after each meeting I shall post the notes prepared for the class in Class Notes

    Grading

    For the course:
    • Homework Papers: 70% (Essay: 40%, Critique: 30%)
    • Participation in class: 30%

    Writing

    You will write and submit six short essays during the course. The topic for the first essay, which is due on Monday, January 16, will be emailed a few days before the course starts.

    Due dates for homework are listed following the schedule, below.
    Email your essay in the format described below to cs3043-staff at cs.wpi.edu

    The following is trite boilerplate, which you have surely seen multiple times, and still, it deserves attention!
    Plan out your papers carefully, starting with an outline. Define the issue(s) briefly, give---if suitable---a state-of-the-art survey, lay out your thesis, and provide supporting arguments. These can be helped by using several references. Although the following discussion refers mostly to large-scale documents, the main ideas there should be helpful also for the short essays we use this term in the course -- see document format and references.

    Administrative Note: Because of technical limitations (of the way I use email) the essays, and your critiquing, must all be submitted in ascii files. If using MS systems, Notepad is your only editor. On varieties of linux use vim or emacs; I believe there is a Notepad for the Mac, or its equivalent. One more detail, to simplify this chore for me, avoid using attachments; put your message in the body of the email. Thank you for your attention.

    Writing Center Tutors

    If you feel your writing skills are weaker than you would wish, and that you are having difficulty trying to present your opinions and point of view, then consider attending WPI's Writing Center. Tutors from the center can be scheduled (best done online, but you may want to go there first) to help you with your homework assignments and project.

    Guidelines --- Peer grading

    A feature of the course: you not only write essays, you get to critique and evaluate them! While the grades are assigned by the instructor, your evaluation is taken into account. Moreover: your critique is part of the grade you get for that week's assignment. It provides 20% of the grade.
    The entire operation is via email.

    The peer grading is completely randomized and anonymized: your essays will be evaluated by another student drawn at random from the set of students who submitted. Each week you evaluate a single paper.

    You need to read and evaluate the paper according to your understanding of the assignment.

    You need to provide two kinds of output: comments, and a grade, writing them below the essay you get mailed, and email it all back. Your comments will be sent to the writer of the essay, with the grade assigned by us.

    The comments therefore need to be directed to the student writer; aimed to show how one of his/her peers understands his writing. For such comments to lead over time to better presentation, they need to be quite explicit and detailed.

    Each of the criteria I mention below needs to be considered in your evaluation and grade, but their relative importance is up to you.

    Criteria:

    A. Does the paper use well the information provided?         Does it answer a question?
            [For some topics the second part would be "Does it reach a conclusion?"]
    B. Is the paper well organized? (assumptions clearly stated, reasons for claims provided, and the like).
    C. Is the writing clear? The language, including terminology, suitable?
    D. Is the paper grammatically correct, and clear of errors/typos?

    The grade you assign is on a scale of 0 to 10.

    Our current plan is to drop the poorest weekly grade when we compute the final grade.

    Academic honesty

    In a course having professional ethics as one of its focal points, issues of academic honesty should be self evident!
    Please familiarize yourself with WPI's Academic Honesty Policy.

    Laptop Use and Notes

    "Recent (2009) work has shown that students who take notes retain more information, and that students who multi-task during class (e.g., with laptops or cell phones) learn less. In fact, those who believed that they gained by multi-tasking, did the worst."
    You can find an interview with the lead researcher in a related work here.

    Laptop use in class is acceptable as long as it is restricted to note taking. Any other activity that distracts you or the people around you, preventing thoughtful participation in the class, is inappropriate.

    Provisions for students with disabilities:

    "If you need special adaptations or accommodations in tests or homework because of a disability, or if you have medical information to share with me, please get to see me as soon as possible. If you have not already done so, students with disabilities who believe that they may need accommodations in this class, are encouraged to contact the Disability Services Office (DSO), as soon as possible to ensure that such accommodations are implemented in a timely fashion. The DSO is located in Daniels Hall, (508) 831-5235."

    Provisions for student absence due to Religious Beliefs:

    Massachusetts state law specifies that a student---
    "who is unable, because of his/her religious beliefs, to attend classes or to participate in any examination, study, or work requirement on a particular day shall be excused from any such examination or study or work requirement, and shall be provided with an opportunity to make up such examination, study, or work requirement which he/she may have missed because of such absence on any particular day; provided, however, that such makeup examination or work shall not create an unreasonable burden upon such school."
    If this applies to you, you must let me know of your need during the first week of classes.

    Tentative Class Outline

    The following outline is tentative. It is possible to achieve the course objectives in different ways, and while there are topics we really should devote some time to, things may change as we go along.


    Nr. Day Date Class Discussion Topics     (Pages in text,   Further reading)   Notes  
    1 Thu 1/12 Introduction, Course Content, Roles of Computation, Cyberethics (Preface, 1-13, Forster: The Machine Stops, Pariser, cyberwar)  Note1  
    2 Thu 1/19 The impact of information processing on Privacy (132-155, Online privacy, Credit records, Computer matching I, II, III)  Note2  
    3 Mon 1/23 The impact of computer communications on Privacy (155-168, in Europe , GenerationalPrivacy, Crypto)  Note3  
    4 Thu 1/26 Ethics, Basic Concepts and Principles (35-62, Bynum)  Note4
    5 Mon 1/30 Ethics and Professional Responsibilities (9-30, 102-113, 125-126,  ACM)  Note5  
    6 Thu 2/2 Professional Ethics: Conflict of Interest.(113-124,  CoI, Pharma, IT-CoI)  Note6  
    7 Mon 2/6 Security and Safety in Cyberspace (173-196,   Brenner, cyberwarriors )  Note7  
    8 Thu 2/9 Computing and Crime (201-224)  Note8  
    9 Mon 2/13 Intellectual Property in Cyberspace (229-260, Google1, 2, 3, 4, 5) Docs-TOS (see section 11))  Note9  
    10 Mon 2/20 Freedom of speech, software & Commerce in Cyberspace (265-295)  Note10  
    11 Thu 2/23 Computers in the Workplace (306-325, FAA I, II, III)  Note11  
    12 Mon 2/27 Impact of Cybertechnology on Community and Self (330-356, Time/MOY)  Note12  
    13 Thu 3/1 Evaluating Technology: Ethical Aspects of Emerging Technologies (361-388, Psychotherapy I, II)
    -----
    14 Fri 3/2 Discussion of current issues;  student presentations(?)
    -----

    Due dates for homework assignments

    HW 1: Essay: Monday, 1/16, 9pm;   Critique: Saturday, 1/21, 9pm.
    HW 2: Essay: Thursday, 1/26, 9pm;   Critique: Tuesday, 1/31, 9pm.
    HW 3: Essay: Monday, 2/6, 9pm;   Critique: Thursday, 2/9, 9pm.
    HW 4: Essay: Monday, 2/13, 9pm;   Critique: Friday, 2/17, 9pm.
    HW 5: Essay: Monday, 2/20, 9pm;   Critique: Friday, 2/24, 9pm.
    HW 6: Essay: Monday, 2/27, 9pm;   Critique: Thursday, 3/1, 9pm.
  • ------------------------------------------
    http://www.cs.wpi.edu/~hofri/3043/index.html


    [WPI] [CS]