NRL HCI Lab VE Graphics Hardware Review


Low-End PC Cards

Chipset (Company) Bits per Pixel Accellerated APIs Board Price Pros Cons
Voodoo3 (3DFX) 16 Glide, Direct3D Voodoo3/3000 $150 Terrific 16-bit 3D performance; low price No 32-bit rendering or z-buffer; limited to 16MB of RAM; lacks large texture support
Riva TNT2 (nVidia) 32 Direct3D, OpenGL Hercules Dynamite TNT2 $246 Fast. Really Fast Be afraid of the setup process. Be very afraid.



Guillemot Xentor 32 $199 Fast Initial boards had a broken install; shipping drivers are a little old



Creative Labs 3D Blaster Riva TNT2 Ultra $200 Fairly fast; Unified driver Unified driver still pretty alpha; older drivers in the box



Diamond Viper 770 $210 Slick 3D control panel; good utilities; decent software bundle Not as highly clockable as other TNT2 boards
Rage 128 (ATI) 32 Direct3D, OpenGL ATI All-in-Wonder 128 $212 Excellent interface for video functions; MPEG-2 video capture Slow 3D performance
Permedia 3 (3DLabs) 32 Direct3D, OpenGL 3Dlabs Create! $212 Robust OpenGL ICD for content-creation apps Poor 3D gaming performance
Savage 4 (S3) 32 Direct3D, OpenGL Diamond Stealth III S540 $115 32MB real cheap; S3TC support; good control panel Slow at high-resolution 3D; minor image-quality issues



Hercules Terminator Beast 99 $125 It's cheap for 32MB Slower than most of the competition
G400 Max (Matrox) 32 Direct3D, OpenGL Matrox Millenium G400Max $220 Fairly fast Direct3D performance; multimonitor support; environmental bump-mapping Poor OpenGL support
Comparison of PC Cards

High-End PC Cards

Chipset (Company) Bits per Pixel Accellerated APIs Board Price Pros Cons
GLINT GMX 2000 (3DLabs) 32 OpenGL Oxygen GMX $2,299

Obsidian2 (Quantum3D) 22 (!) Direct3D, Glide, MiniGL X-Series $??? Very fast Multiple Voodoo2 Chips
Best used with HeavyMetal PC System
Wildcat - Several Flavors (Intergraph) 32 OpenGL, Direct3D Wildcat 4000 $5,900 (inc. Dell PC) Seems very fast on the Viewperf scores



Wildcat 4105 $6,900 (inc. Integraph TDZ-2000) Seems very fast on the Viewperf scores
Cobalt (SGI) 32 OpenGL, Direct3D Visual Workstation 320 $5,900 (inc. SGI PC)




Visual Workstation 540 $7,500 (inc. SGI PC)

Viewperf Benchmark


Compiled by Robert W. Lindeman (gogo@seas.gwu.edu)