Reviewing

Criteria

Assignments

1. Branki, Bridges and Wallis:				FAXed
   Collaborative learning agents
   Reviewers: 
	Dave Brown 		Maybe
	Tomasz Arciszewski 	.
	Alex Duffy		Accept with revisions
   Result: {accept} {DB & AD reviews sent to author}

2. Grecu and Brown:					grecu.ps
   Dimensions of learning in agent-based design
   Reviewers: {To be determined by Alex and Ashok}
	XX			Accept with slight modifications
	YY			Accept
   Result:  Accept (reviews sent to author)

3. Manfaat, Duffy and Lee:				manfaat.ps
   Generalisation of spatial layouts
   Reviewers: {To be determined by Dave and Ashok}
	XX			Accept
	YY			.
   Result:  {accept}

4. Prabhakar and Basu:					prabhakar.bad.ps 
   Learning to design by model composition from past 
   derivational design experiences.
   Reviewers: 
	Ashok Goel		Accept, but probably not for presentation.
	Yoram Reich   		Accept, with improvements
   Result: Accept  (reviews sent to author)

5. Schwabacher, Ellman and Hirsch:			schwab.ps   
   Learning to select prototypes and reformulations for design
   Reviewers: 
	Alex Duffy 		.
	DLG			Accept, with polishing
	Mary Lou Maher		Accept
   Result: Accept (reviews sent to author)

6. Tang: 						tang.ps  
   An integrated application of machine learning techniques in 
   Ingelligent CAD support
   Reviewers:  
	Ashok Goel		Accept
	Mary Lou Maher		Accept, with rewrite
   Result: Accept  (reviews sent to author)

7. Brandish, Hague and Taleb-Bendiab:			brandish.txt 
   M-LAP: A machine learning apprentice agent for computer supported 
   engineering design
   Reviewers: 		
	David Brown		Accept, with polishing.
	Yoram Reich 		Accept, with improvements
   Result: Accept  (reviews sent to author)


Ashok's FAX is 404-894-9846 Yoram Fax: + 972 3 6407617 Tom's FAX, (703) 993-1706