Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing

Reviewer's Evaluation Form

The latest reviewing form is on
the web pages of the new Editor at

Version: Aug 2010

  • Rating Scale:
    1 = lowest   (e.g., reject)
    5 = average   (e.g., accept with major modifications)
    10 = highest   (e.g., accept without revisions or with minor revisions)
  • Please rate the paper and its presentation in the categories listed below.
  • If you encounter any problems with the on-line review submission process (questions, confusion, etc.), please contact the administrator via e-mail at:
  • Please complete ALL the entries. Thank You!

The AIEDAM Reviewer's Evaluation Form

Reviewer's Full Name:
E-mail Address:
Paper Number:
Paper Title:
Version Reviewed:
(Please do not forget to enter all the information above)

Topic suitable for this Journal:
Style and Organization:
Technical Quality:
Has the Research Been Well Evaluated?
Overall Recommendation:
Consider it to be a:
Your Confidence in Your Recommendation:

Comments to the Editor:

Comments to the Author(s): Quality of Writing, Figures and References
Number of AIEDAM Papers Cited:
Comments to the Author(s): Suitable Extra References to AIEDAM Papers

Comments to the Author(s): Technical Review


(Please check that you have entered ALL the information above)


Thank you very much for completing the AIEDAM Review Form

Return to the AIEDAM Mainpage

Send Journal Inquiries & Comments to:
Copyright © 2010 Cambridge University Press
Mon Aug 23 19:38:43 EDT 2010