Kathi's Journal of India, 2006
|
This page contains observations from my first trip to India in
December 2006. My husband, Shriram, is from Bangalore. This trip was
his first to India in 15 years, so it was a bit of adventure for us
both. We stayed with his parents at their current home in his
old neighborhood (they live in the US, but maintain a place here as
well). Being in a home with family gave me a rather different feel
than many first-time visitors would have. I've certainly seen the
city in a rather different order than others would. Photos are by me
or Shriram.
|
Find your Lane
8 Dec 2006
Paris CDG airport is neatly organized into terminals, wings, and
check in counters, all numbered. In theory, the departure boards list
the wings and counter numbers handling each flight. These are easier
to use if you arrive at the right wing in the first place and your
flight departure time hasn't changed by half an hour. Nevertheless,
we found the numbered lane for our flight, only to learn that the
lines are for economy class and the business-class lines are not
adjacent. Those who regularly fly international business class
probably just know these things; for those in business class on
frequent flyer miles, this little gaffe puts you back in place.
Flight boarding contrasts the the ultra-organization of European
flight check-in. Everyone jostles into a line and pushes on board,
with only the two ticket agents to regulate the flow.
Arrival and immigration in Bangalore lacked the chaotic drama I'd
expected of overstuffed suitcases, diverse crowds, and a clatter of
languages. There were a handful of immigration counters, with no
nationality-based lines as in Europe and the States. Finding your
baggage is easy--there is only one carosel--and everyone filters out
in orderly pace. I suspect our eventual 3am arrival had a lot to do
with how subdued entry experience.
Roads in the daytime are chaotic, a jumble of motorbikes, minivans,
buses, carts, cows, cars, auto-rickshaws, and bicycles. The familiar
regulators of western roads, traffic lights and lane markings, are
absent or ignored. Vehicles dart everywhere, constantly filling and
creating empty spaces. Honking is ubiquitous: it announces one's
intended occupancy of a space, whether or not another is threatening
to grab it. There is a lovely, seductive rhythm to this combination
of movement and honking, readily broken when one has to cross the
street. Frogger (the video game) is a good approximation.
|
|
Admist the traffic swirl, I had a sudden vision of software flows.
Formal methods researchers (of which I'm one) like to bemoan the lack
of software quality, yet much software does run sufficiently well much
of the time. Lack of formal structure certainly makes it hard to
understand or predict software behavior, but the system nonetheless
hangs together. It can be maddening, it can be dangerous, but we're
still standing. That's how I felt after crossing my first street
here. The Bangalore roads are a beautiful illustration of how
functionality emerges from minimal structure. I have no idea what the
accident/death rate is, though.
Soundtracks
9 Dec 2006
After 48 hours in India, I am most struck my the sounds. Some, such
as ringtones and airplanes, as familiar in isolation, but the global
web of sound here has a bizarre quality all its own. Endless chords
include sputtering engines, honking, construction, and the cries of
street vendors as they wheel cars full of fruit, vegetables, and
spices through the streets. (So far, I've recognized only the call of
the vendor for a brownish-greyish tropical fruit that I don't much
care for.) A tape recorder would be far more useful than a camera for
documenting this trip.
The vicious thumping of laundry against stones provided the first
morning's alarm clock. The second morning, a jarring out-of-tune jazz
approximation drove us from our room into the front hall, only to grow
louder. The musician ended up being a navascarum player in the
driveway of the house, blasting away to no tune that my Indian family
could identify. They believe the player is related to one who has
been in the neighborhood for decades, but who apparently knew only a
single song. This one was at least new, if unrecognizable.
Most surreal moment so far: on our first car trip here, the closed
windows and classical Indian music on the radio blocked the usual
street noise. As the cars moved against the music, the lines of the
motorbikes became graceful and interwoven. It seemed so serene
compared to the choreography of honking horns, yet oddly out of place
knowing the original score.
Finger Exercises
10 Dec 2006
I've been eagerly anticipating the food since we began planning this
trip, and I've not been disappointed. In addition to my mother
in-law's usual good cooking, we've enjoyed various sweets and savories
from take-away stands and restaurants. The chutneys are fresh, the
idlees (dumplings) light, and the burfi (milk fudge) melts in the
mouth. Three days in, my greatest culinary-related delight has been
finally experiencing a finger bowl.
South Indians eat with their hands rather than with utensils. This is
easy enough to master with naan and curry, but quite a bit more
challenging with rice, yogurt, and watery stews. Genuine hand-eating
requires that only the right hand touch the food (so you have to be
able to tear apart breads using just the fingers of one hand) _and_
that the right hand stay clean below the knuckles. It took a couple
of years to master, but being able to eat properly with my fingers has
been a mark of authenticity and cultural awareness on multiple occasions.
Hand-based eating, which occurs even in fine restaurants, leaves the
problem of cleaning the hand after the meal. Protocol demands a
"finger bowl", which Indian restaurants at home approximate with a
warm towelette or a trip to the washroom. I finally got to use a real
finger bowl today. After the main meal (but before dessert), the
waiters came around with individual bowls of warm rose-colored liquid
with a slice of lemon. My understanding of protocol indicated that
this should be a finger bowl, but something this colorful and
sweet-smelling, (not to mention garnished) seemed more suitable for
drinking. One of our companions dunked the fingers of both hands in
the warm water and squeezed the lemon over her fingers. While I
suspect this was a high-end finger bowl experience, it was a luxurious
way to clean up after a meal.
Pedestrian Thoughts
11 Dec 2006
I find myself paying a lot of attention to people's feet here.
Partly, I'm stricken by how many people walk and work barefoot
(including many of the auto rickshaw drivers and construction
workers), especially given the uneven sidewalks and general street
clutter. Most shoe-wearing people seem to wear sandals of some form.
Shoes that slip on and off easily are very convenient for going to
temples, as shoes must be left outside the temple entrances. I also
suspect that sandals are cheaper, cooler, and easier to wash off than
other shoe options. Shoe stores here carry a terrific range of
sandals and we picked up a set to leave at temple entrances during our
travels.
I'm strangely conscious of the lack of nail polish on my toes. I
suspect this comes from contrasting all the vibrant colors and
patterns used in women's clothing here with my somewhat blander travel
wardrobe. I don't feel out of place in western clothing (even though
most women wear Indian styles of dress), but I do notice the lack of
color. I end up looking down at my toes a lot (necessary to navigate
the roads and sidewalks), and they seem a prime way to blend in better
from a color perspective.
A friend took us to a traditional dance performance. Traditional
dance is done barefoot, but with jingly bangles around the ankles.
This gives the effect of tap shoes, but with a bit less precision in
the sound. Part of the technique appears to be in controlling the
vibrancy of the jingle through the foot movements, the rest in the
gestures that suggest different deities and requests. Before the
show, we heard a 20 minute Powerpoint presentation by the head of the
state tourism council about the future of local tourism. I learned
that the state sent 8 representatives to a tourism conference this
year and that the German representatives received them very well.
None of the other tidbits stood out nearly as well.
Road sports
12 Dec 2006
We've begun using auto rickshaws (simply called "autos") to get around
the city. An auto rickshaw is a three wheeler with room for 2-3
people in the back seat. It's much like a cycle-based rickshaw in
concept, though motorized abd fully covered on the top and partly on
the sides. Local autos have bright yellow tops and are as ubiquitous
as taxicabs in New York or Mexico City. They form the intermediate
level of transport here, being between motorbikes and cars on the
vehicle scale, and between buses and car-based taxis on the
price/comfort scales. Some of them are ornately decorated, with
garlands on the front, icons of deities or movie starts on the dash,
or artwork on the inner sides and roof. We rode in one all done up in
a quilted-form of plastic seating upolstery. It rather reminded me of
the art car parade, one of our favorite events in Houston.
Riding in an auto brings the Banglore roads right into your lap.
Vehicles ride and weave so close together that it would be easy to
grab onto someone in the vehicle next to you. The exhaust from
surrounding motorbikes and autos blows into the cab. Luckily, the
drivers turn the autos off (in an attempt to save gas) when stopped at
one of the rare traffic lights here. The Dolby-surround horn noise
keeps you constantly aware of the vehicles about to pass on either
side. It rather reminds me of the way in which one is part of the
water while kayaking: the road dust runs over you as the water runs
down my arms and onto my head when paddling a kayak. I taste the road
much as I taste the waters as I paddle. It's visceral and real, if a
bit throat-clogging.
The bike-handling skills of these motorbike drivers astounds me. I
road cycle a bit, but am very uncomfortable riding in packs because I
don't trust my skills riding so close to other bikers. Vehicles here
pack in as tightly as a pack of road cyclists, though here the
vehicles are not all of the same size, speed, or weight, nor are they
necessarily going in the same direction. The motorbike drivers
squeeze into the smallest spaces around other vehicles, usually
without missing a beat. I think I'd know I'd truly conquered this
place, and developed some serious balls, if I could ride a motorbike
in the height of the day without hitting the brakes until I got home.
I've decided that next time I come here, I'm going to attach a small
bicycle horn to my handbag so I can toot with the rest of them. It's
a universal language here, this honking, and pedestrians are
disadvantaged not being able to join in the conversation.
Truth and Beauty
13 Dec 2006
Everything I read before coming here referred to Bangalore as the
cosmopolitan city of India. Growing up near Manhatten, and having
traveled a lot in the US and Europe, I had a good mental image of what
a cosmopolitan city would look like: clean lines, lots of glass,
ethnic restaurants, nice hotels, etc. I found almost none of this in
my first few days in Bangalore. The city is certainly
multi-lingual--lots of people speak at least some English--but it
lacks the kemptness and the overt classy style that I've always
associated with being cosmopolitan.
Today I finally encountered a bit of the cosmopolitan sheen I'd
expected. A friend took us to a yuppie Italian restaurant for lunch.
The styling was like a good place back home, with prices almost (but
not quite) to match. It, and I, felt totally out of place. We walked
past some of the branches of western stores trying to look glitzy in
their somewhat run-down outer buildings. None of it felt right. As
we got closer to the neighborhood where Shriram had gone to school,
we explored some of the bookstores and side streets he used to hang at
as a teenager. Tons of bookstores stocking mostly English-language
books. Cookbooks from all parts of the world. Guidebooks on how to
understand the dialects and regional culture from other
English-speaking parts of the world. Little signs here and there that
people here are broader than the local region, broader than just
India. Those signs are just a bit harder to see in a place that hasn't
had the resources or desire to rebuild itself to appear cosmopolitan
in the language of the west.
Ironically, I borrowed a friend's copy of "The Beauty Myth" (by Naomi
Wolf) a couple of days ago. It grabbed my attention as I started
thinking about, and feeling guilty about, the nail polish. The book
talks about the culture and expectation of beauty constructed around
American womanhood, and the ways in which it holds women back by
forcing us to remain focused on our looks rather than on who we are.
My reaction to "cosmopolitan Bangalore" drove home the Beauty Myth
I've absorbed. Here I was looking for a gloss on the city, rather
than at what values the city projects in its more organic guises. As
we came home through the local bazaar, those organic features were all
the more potent. This place has felt very real since I arrived, but
now it's starting to have depth as well. Bangalore certainly has its
surface-level problems that may slow its economic growth (road and
sidewalk infrastructure among them). I just hope that more of the
people who come here will be able to look for the unique ways that
this city can develop itself without trying to force it into a shallow
replica of somewhere else. Given what I've been hearing about the
California-style suburbs sprouting outside of town, I'm a bit wary.
More importantly, though, I'm humbled.
Role Reversal
13 Dec 2006
Back home, we rarely go out for Italian food. Partly, Italian food
for vegetarians isn't all that interesting (another pasta primavera,
ma'am?) and partly my ancestors were Italian so we cook a lot of that
cuisine at home anyway. When we do go out for Italian, it's for some
nice form of stuffed pasta with a sturdy sauce and minimal veggies.
Today, we ended up in an Italian restaurant because a friend needed
some blander food. Shriram and I spotted salad on the menu and
jumped at it. Greens! Veggies! We were able to count on two hands
the number of veggies we'd had (not times, veggies themselves) since
arriving in India. Our diet here has been more of blends of rice and
legumes with sauces made from blends of herbs, with potatoes on the
side. We decided that veggies were most assuredly in order, and ate
them with gusto.
At home, we go out for Indian when we are tired of eating too much
pasta and want to get some veggies (usually in a North Indian curry
sauce, but veggies just the same -- our local Indian place, Kabob and
Curry, is very health conscious while also being quite tasty). We
explicitly choose a non-veggie night when we go out for Italian. Our
sudden desire to avail of the chance to get veggies at an Italian
place gave us both a good laugh, and suggested that a platter of kale
stew will be high on the list of things to make when we get home.
Yes Bangalore, there is a Santa Claus
15 Dec 2006
This year is my first away from the western world at
Christmastime. While I'm not religious and could do without the
holiday onslaught starting immediately after Halloween (Continental
was playing jingle bells in the plane when we left the US on Nov
2nd--good lord!), I expect to see lights, stars, and lots of red and
green in December. I love the festiveness in the air, the cookies,
the lights, the cookies, and the music (starting after around Dec 8th
or so). I've been away from the US for the holidays before, but
always in some place such as the UK or Switzerland that keeps the
spirit alive (with almost as much commercialism as in the states).
When we left for this trip, I wondered what it would be like to spend
the holidays without the holidays, and brought along the advent
calendar that my Mom sent (one every year, thanks Mom) to follow the
season from India.
So here I am, opening the little advent windows every morning in a
state of utter disconnect. It isn't the warm weather, as I lived 4
years in Houston and got used to Santa in shorts. It's the total lack
of Christmas anything. No signs, no mention, so jingle bell rock, no
salvation army ringers. Most of the time, I don't notice it missing,
but if I get reminded of the date, something seems oddly out of whack,
as if I've suddenly forgotten my phone number or other core piece of
identifying information.
The Christmas season finally showed itself today. We'd gone
looking for one of Shriram's former high school teachers, who is now
the principal at another school. The private high schools here seem
to all be religiously affiliated, even if that religious touch is
lightly applied. Shriram attended a Jesuit high school that replaced
catechism classes with "moral science" (which he parsed as "moral
signs" for some time -- ask him about the lesson on "sex and violence"
sometime). The school we were visiting is Christian-based, so there
was a tree with lights in the foyer, Merry Christmas banners hanging
around, and a set of asian-pop-rock covers of carols over the
playground loudspeakers (including "Auld Lang Syne", so getting ahead
of ourselves holiday-wise isn't limited to the US). I've seen Santas
in the entryways of other Christian schools here, and even a (somewhat
skinny) Santa among the sarees in a clothing shop in the western-style
commericial district). I also passed one street vendor hawking cheap
santa hats, though he didn't make a single sale that I saw.
There's no real insight to this entry, no lead-in to a comment on
religion in India. Just a reflection on how muted Christmas is here,
as those of you reading this are in the thick of it all if you're
following as I write these notes. It will be odd to get back to the
states right as it is all ending. I haven't missed the cookies one
bit this year, perhaps due to the number of pieces of burfi I've eaten
instead. Gingerbread burfi hasn't hit Bangalore yet. Perhaps there's
an opportunity waiting to happen. Watch your Christmas packages from
us in 2007.
Cents and Sensibility
15 Dec 2006
The costs of things here, when converted to dollars, still floors
me. A taxi ride across town (5-6 miles) costs 75 cents. Good quality
cotton shirts, 5 dollars. A glass of fresh-pressed pineapple juice,
50 cents. You can feed four people lunch for 2 dollars at a sidewalk
take-away food bar. Shriram and I decided to pig out on dinner
tonight and only managed to spend 5 dollars (having eaten hearty
appetizers at each of two roadside stands, followed by a sitdown
dinner with drinks and dessert). While these prices obviously are
consistent with the wage standards here, contrasting them to my own
earning power makes me stop and think sometimes.
A couple of our meals have been as more yuppie-style places with
prices to match. Some of these have been protocol, when one of his
old friends who has done well for himself here has taken us out to eat
in styles consistent with his financial position. These places aren't
fancy in the sense that we think of Michelin-star restaurants in the
west, but they are clearly very upscale and the desserts cost as much
as a whole dinner at one of our favorite stands. Once was with a
friend who had a hankering for a particular place that is clearly
catering to the "up and coming" crowd. While the prices were still
fair in dollars, they were on par with what I'd expect to pay at a
standard middle-class establishment in the states.
Price differences here do not reflect food quality as much as
atmosphere. The food in these fancier places has been good, but the
places I've wanted to revisit have all been in the lower price
category (perhaps the extra frying has something to do with it). In
some cases, the menu items are similar. But one level is targeted at
middle-class Indians and the other at rising upper-class
multinationals. Back at home, if I eat one meal that costs an order
of magnitude more than another, the more expensive one is usually a
lot tastier, healthier, and smaller than the cheaper meal. The
difference between a slice of pizza and hand-rolled tortelloni is
noticable. Here, the more expensive food is perhaps a bit healthier
(not as many fried foods, though not all cheaper options are of this
sort), but the portions are similarly sized and the flavors simply not
that different. The more upscale places do offer certain guarantees
(filtered water instead of the risk of local tap water) and amenities
(toilet paper instead of a rinse bucket), so the extra cost goes to
something. That something just isn't as much culinary as I'm used to.
Overall, this trip has let me experience aspects of being very
wealthy, and I'm finding it interesting which parts of that existence
I like and which I could leave aside. Flying business class? Keep.
Having a driver when a car is required? Definitely keep. Being
driven everywhere? Reject: local trips in autos is too much fun and
doesn't require the hassle of parking and finding the driver again at
the end. Upscale dining? Only for special occasions, and only for
really good food.
Jewelry and clothing? Not grabbing me. Silk is everywhere here,
and while it has a sleek look, it simply doesn't interest me. Too
heavy, at least as it seems used in sarees and kurtas. The gold
doesn't appeal to me either. I love the clothing styles here, but I'd
rather them in soft cotton instead of fine silk. I'm still sorting
out any implications of all of this, but in the meantime, it does mean
that the merchants who hope to make good money off of westerners with
disposable income and appreciation for value in finery aren't getting
much benefit from my visit here.
Shake, Rattle and Roll
16 Dec 2006
Every south indian I know does a little head-shaking gesture that
has always reminded me of those bobbling-head dashboard dogs (or
Mexican turtle toys, if you've been to the main market in Mexico
City). At home, the head bob usually happens concurrently with
someone saying "yeah, sure" or "of course". I've always gotten a real
kick out of this move, the mechanics of which confound me as do those
of cricket bowling. Only the head moves, in a twisting, rolling,
figure-8-ish motion, while the face wears a decidedly non-commital
expression. It requires neck muscles that I apparently don't use
much; Shriram laughs in horror whenever I try it.
Here in India, the head bob is ubiquitous and covers a wider range
of situations. It seems to generally be a form of acknowledgement.
Ask for the bill at a restaurant, head bob from waiter. Ask for the
price of an item at a market, head bob from clerk as they state the
price. Ask an auto driver for a route, head bob again. It sometimes
stands for "thank you", sometimes for "I heard you", and sometimes
seems to happen simply because south indians learn the head bob from
birth and can't help it. I'm practicing, as being able to bob is a
basic form of communication that belongs in a "10 essential phrases
for travelers" volume (along with honking).
I actually lied a bit earlier -- almost every south indian I know
does the head bob. Shriram is my one exception. The head bob came
from indian friends who came to the US only for grad school (Shriram
came as an undergrad), or from relatives who lived in India or for
only a short time in the states. Shriram's head has never bobbed,
and it was one of the subtle ways in which he stood apart from my
other Indian friends as more of a westerner.
A couple of days ago, over lunch with one of his Indian friends, I
swore I saw his head bob. I jumped, then stared. Didn't happen
again, so I figured I was hallucinating. It happened again over
dinner, at which point I couldn't help but comment on it with
astonished delight, as if to say that he was more Indian than he
usually lets on when we're in the states. He grinned, did it again
for show, and has been merrily bobbing along ever since. He's
defending himself on the grounds that this is a necessary part of the
communication protocol. Yeah, sure, but deep down, I think he's
letting a little more Indian out this week. Not so much as to stop
wearing shorts (which pegs him immediately as a NRI=non-resident
Indian), but enough that I see more of his roots. They were one of
the things I'd hoped to see here, but I'll be the first to admit that
the head bob was not something I came expecting to see.
Off to loosen my neck muscles ...
Between Rocks and a Hayed Place
18 Dec 2006
Our journey outside of Bangalore took us onto the national highway
system. These roads are (generally) paved and two lanes in each
direction. I suspect they resemble the pre-interstate routes that
cross the USA: mostly decent roads that pass through numbers of small
towns and villages. A few features are distinctly different, however.
Indian highways have the same variety of vehicles (motorized or
animal-drawn) as the city streets, so speed varies continually
(especially when an animal cart comes up the highway the wrong way).
Speed bumps are not announced in advance (the sign is at the bump) and
are designed to really make you feel it if you hit one quickly.
Temporary gates sometimes block parts of the road to slow traffic down
(everyone has to funnel through the space left for a single car). And
there are no rest areas (though some appear under construction).
Two sights stood out on the roads: petrol stations and heavily-loaded
vehicles. Petrol stations, even the older ones, are incredibly sleek
and shiny. Most other roadside buildings are shack or small-warehouse
style buildings with only the ads (often for oil companies) bearing
fresh paint. Often, petrol stations consist of no more than 4
gleaming pumps on a dirt lot; newer ones have the small convenience
stores common in the States. These stock less by way of junk food,
however, as roadside stalls selling fresh Indian snacks are all along
the roadsides (vada versus fritos? no contest, despite similar
deep-fried fat content). I took it as a sign that road-travel is on
the rise and will become much more of a business here (major
limited-access highway developments are already underway).
Vehicles of all shapes and sizes carry all sorts of cargo along the
highways. We passed one bicycle loaded down with about 40 5-gallon
pots, another carrying a large 15-foot wide bundle of (what looked
like) bamboo poles. One animal cart bore a pyramid of quarry-size
rocks. Others were piled with 10-foot high haystacks with a farmer
perched on top like a cherry on a mountain of whipped cream. The
animals pulling these carts seemed at their limits: the team pulling
one hay cart were both leaning precariously inward, yet balanced just
enough to not fall down. A real image of "back-breaking" labor. US
highways are generally void of images of the lives of small farmers,
instead bearing only the trucks of large-scale commercial enterprise
or leisure travellers. Indian highways still haven't separated the
poor/rural from the leisured/industrial.
In another sense, though, Indian roads separate wheat from chaff.
On the local roads, it was common to suddenly find the road strewn
thick with hay. Vehicles have no option but to drive over the hay,
which does some of the thrashing work for the farmers. The farmers
would be doing some hand-trashing by the side of the road, but
exploiting the cars for as much as possible. Gives a whole new
meaning to the term "multi-use highway".
Where Have All the Flowers Gone?
19 Dec 2006
I've always associated India with children, partly because our
Indian relatives more often ask whether we are having them (the
cousins all have multiple kids) and partly because the media images I
usually see of India involve poverty-stricken children. I expected
India to be positively teeming with kids. In the first 10 days,
however, I barely saw any kids at all. We'd see them in school yards,
but there was no sign of toddlers during the day or any kids on the
weekends (teenagers, yes, but not younger kids). Perhaps toddlers are
home with older family during the day. It really caught me off-guard
to not see them with mothers in the street markets, though.
We spent a few days traveling outside of Bangalore. One afternoon,
Shriram and I took a walk on a road leading to a rural farm village.
Suddenly, we'd been marked: about ten kids were charging for us from a
side road (school had just let out). They surrounded us with cries
for "pens" and "chocolate" (we had neither). Shriram talked to them
for a few minutes though. They wanted to know where he was from, why
we were on their village road, who I was, and where my mother lives.
Their curiosity was delightful and I wished we had some trinkets to
share with them. They also offered to go fetch us some fresh nuts
from a local field. It was one of those fine travel moments of seeing
a place from its roots, and I wished I could speak a bit of the local
language to join in the conversation.
Inquiries about our own (lack of) children were surprisingly sparse
and discreet. A family friend asked whether our marriage had any
"issues": that term referred to kids in multiple conversations about
family composition. I also noted that when older Indian women did
suggest that we have kids, they talked about how wonderful the baby
years were, with a suggestion that the older years were less
rewarding. This contrasts sharply with the comments from my women
cohorts here, who may or may not like the baby stage, but uniformly
enjoy their kids becoming interactive and conversational. My sample
size on both fronts is too small to generalize from, but I wondered
whether the Indian women enjoyed the activity of the baby stage
because of the activity and role it gives beyond housework, which
seems to define many older women. The older women I met didn't seem
to have interests outside of home and family, so I imagine the bustle
of babies could be very welcoming.
I, Object
20 Dec 2006
Insights from reading "Beauty Myth" notwithstanding, I've never
given much though to being objectified. In parts of India, however,
my role is clear: I am a source of money. I had expected this to a
certain extent: guidebooks and friends who have gone to India in the
past all warned about the swirl of begging that often surrounds
westerners. In practice, I found very little of this (perhaps 2-3
instances, all at tourist attractions, but never in the cities).
Shriram remarked that outright begging was down substantially since he
was last there.
Entrepreunership, however, has given a new face to requests for
money. As soon as the car pulled up near an attraction, postcard
vendors would surround the doors and approach the windows. Before I
could even get out of the car to see the site we had come to visit,
several people would have shoved cards under my nose for me to buy.
Others would follow us to the entrance with trinkets ("I made these
myself madam"). The cycle would start again as we tried to leave, but
oddly less aggressively than when we arrived. I don't begrudge any of
these folks for trying to make a living, and it is certainly far
better that begging be replaced by commerce. The problem is that
being surrounded by so many people selling the same stuff makes me
unlikely to buy from any one of them. A survival strategy of
sunglasses and staring at the ground becomes the protocol for getting
into and out of cars, none of which has the affect that the vendors
want. Part of me feels badly about this--I know those few rupees are
far more valuable to them than to me. But I lack the strength to
support one then fend off the rest, because then I feel like I've
somehow made it personal. Instead, we all become objects.
Such encounters with small-scale vendors were uncomfortable, but
encounters with shop keepers were aggrevating. At one state-run
crafts emporium, we were verbally assulted with calls to look at this
or that from the moment we stepped into the hall. It was impossible
to approach a counter without the salesperson literally thrusting the
items they wanted you to buy under your eyes. I'll admit I'm not
comfortable with confrontational shopping in general, but this was a
whole new level, and this at a place that I would have expected to
have a sense of wanting customers to find something they wanted to buy
(unlike with the postcard vendors who are trying to make a more
immediate living). We left in protest. At least when stores view you
as an object at home, they are subtle about it. I'll need to learn
strategies for handling this before our next trip.
Let Lying Dogs Sleep
22 Dec 2006
Animals are routine in the ebb and flow of Indian street life.
Cows wander the streets munching on trash and sometimes resting on
sidewalks. Animal-drawn carts trot alongside the cars and autos.
Dogs are everywhere. They are all the same type (mongrels), and come
in two colors: dusty black and dusty brown. All are skinny and some
are clearly ill. The most striking aspect of the dogs, though, is
that the vast majority of them are lying down: on the sidewalks,
streets, sacks of grains, rocks, or anywhere else a dog might find a
place to curl up. They bear a weariness that doesn't show on the
faces of people, but reflects the conditions of street life. They
appear to be asleep, but without that look of relaxation that often
accompanies restful sleep. Overall, they are the most striking
picture of fatigue on offer in Bangalore and, unlike the humans, they
never show hopeful faces (unlike Western puppies, whom seem to believe
that love in the form of biscuit could come from anywhere). It was
almost as if amongst the vitality and promise of Bangalore, the dogs
serve to record some fundamental truth that the humans suppress. No
doubt there are parts of the country where both humans and dogs where
those same looks. In vibrant Bangalore, the contrast barks at you
visually from every push cart under which the dogs sniff for scraps.
Skirting Fashion Expectations
23 Dec 2006
A few months ago, a friend and I were talking about our respective
discoveries of "female" clothing in our 30s, by which we meant items
like heels and stretch pants, rather than the khaki-and-loafers
uniform of many college professors (outside of the humanities). I've
long felt at a loss for an identifiable "style" in my clothing since
giving up the jeans and sweatshirts I'd had since high school, and
I've had a side eye out for style options in mid-adult clothes.
I rather fell in love with women's clothing in India, specifically
kurtas (tunics), which are generally worn with western pants (for
short kurtas) or pyjama-like bottoms called kamese (for long kurtas).
It took several days to figure out why I was so enthralled with these:
I often wear tunic-ish tops at home, but they don't come close to
matching the draw I felt towards kurtas. The appeal, I realized, lies
in the way they move. Kurta/kamese give the flow of dresses and
skirts without the need to wear stockings (the threat of which keeps
me from wearing skirts that don't go with sandals). There is
something fluidly feminine about them, while still being comfortable
and practical.
In the west, baseline clothing styles (at least in the circles I
move in) are similar between men and women, be they jeans or tailored
jackets. In India, women have their own style of clothes in sarees
and kamese. This isn't entirely true, as (muslim) men often wear
kurta/kamese as well, but the normal men's style is more of a western
shirt and pant, which leaves women a clothing form all their own.
Something felt liberating about that, about not being expected to
blend in visually with the men. Indian women stand out in their
clothing due to the vivid colors and patterns. The color splashing
from women's clothing often hits like cold water: it resembles a US
academic procession, but without all the pomp. It's a terrific
distraction for the senses when the traffic and dust from the dry
season would otherwise start to overwhelm.
There is also something liberating in a common dress standard for
women that crosscuts class lines. Fabrics and embellishments suggest
economic status, but the core form and style is universal. While such
uniformity may sound stifling to some, the liberal use of color and
pattern still gives lots of room for individual expression. That
said, the shiny new stores promote western clothes (labeling the local
clothes as "ethnic wear"), and several younger women sport western
shirts and pants. I suspect the streets of India will be much less
colorful and flowing a generation from now. I hope not though, as
there is a breathtaking grace and elegance to how Indian women of all
situations carry themselves in their "ethnic" clothes. For
comparison, look at western women in sarees: we may figure out how to
wrap the cloth around us properly, but we sure don't carry them off
well (kurta/kamese is much easier). Perhaps it's as genetic as the
head-bob.
Comfort Food
24 Dec 2006
A couple of years ago, Shriram and I were trying to decide what to
have for dinner and I commented that we shouldn't have Indian because
we'd had Indian for lunch. Naturally, he pointed out that Indians eat
Indian food twice in one day. Nevertheless, I wondered whether eating
the same cuisine for days on end would get monotonous. To my delight,
it did not, but my introduction to the highway system left me a bit
woozy and craving light and bland food, which is harder to come by in
Indian cuisine, so we went looking for a change.
Enter Indo-Chinese cooking. When I was growing up, Chinese was the
ubiquitous "ethnic" food: if a town we were driving through had
non-American food (other than pizza), it had Chinese. Well, Chinese
seems to be the default ethnic food in India as well. Many
restaurants are marked "multi-cuisine", which seems to mean that it
offers both Indian and Chinese (at least) dishes. We had Chinese
several nights, and it was fairly similar to Chinese food in the
states except with many more vegetarian options (and I hear with more
MSG). One standard is sweet corn soup, an old favorite of Shriram's
that's hard to find, much less in veg versions, in the US.
Is Chinese the international default "ethnic" food? Perhaps not in
the UK, where Indian is a bit more common for historical reasons. It
wasn't in Japan, which didn't have non-Japanese places in any number.
Certainly China would need a different default. I'm just curious how
Chinese came to be the default in India. Restaurants from other
ethnicities were a rare sight, even in cosmopolitan Bangalore. In
addition to the many multi-cuisine places, I seem to recall seeing one
Thai, one Japanese, and one Italian, plus a handful of upscale bistro
style places with diverse menus. I expected much more, particularly
from other South/East Asian locales, such as Singapore. Instead, we
were mostly surrounded by Indian restaurants.
To be fair, Indian cuisine offer very different regional styles, so a
set of 6 Indian restaurants in India would offer far more diversity
than 6 Indian restaurants in the US (most of which seem to offer
the same menu, with the rare exception of a South Indian restaurant).
One can go out to eat at an Indian restaurant in India and get totally
different food than what one would get at home (naan, for example, is
restaurant food in Shriram's family). And the styles of restaurants
vary from sit-down, to take-away places with tables to stand at, to
chaat (a kind of snack) bars. The experience was never the same two
places in a row, which no doubt kept monotony at bay.
Fresh fruit juice also deserves a mention here. Most restaurants
offer a variety of freshly-made juice, which is a handy alternative to
bottled water. I've never had such flavorful pineapple and grape
juices, not to mention sweet lime juice. I suppose I shouldn't have
been surprised that fresh fruit juice had the rich flavor of, er,
fresh fruit but the delta was beyond what I'm used to between
Tropicana and most fresh squeezed orange juices in the states.
[The photo at right is of Ghandi Bazaar, one of the two main markets
in Bangalore and just a few blocks from the house. This
photo was taken on the fruit block; other blocks cover
herbs, veggies, and flowers.]
|
|
Christmas Wishes
25 Dec 2006
Updating an earlier remark about Christmas: Christmas did
eventually come to Bangalore. Not in the all-encompassing way it does
at home, but there nonetheless. Around Dec 21st, many retail stores
painted santa/snowmen images on the windows and sidewalk vendors
started selling santa hats. The petrol station near my in-laws' place
had two stick-thin santas pumping gas on the 25th. One wore a jacket
in the just-above-knee length of a kurta (Indian tunic) -- I'd
discussed Indo-western hybrid fashion with a friend, but this was my
first sighting of it in a holiday line.
Basically, Christmas is viewed as an excuse for a party. Most of
the nicer restaurants throw dinners and parties, much like New Year's
bashes in the states. The 25th was a government holiday (though a
neighbor said that they take whatever the closest Friday/Monday is to
the 25th as the holiday each year, not necessarily the 25th itself).
It's a quieter event, in that Christmas music is notably absent (and
seemed rather out of place when inserted from my iPod). No jingles,
cookies, salvation army bells, or other sensory inputs that
I generally associate with the season at home.
I found it ironic that the holidays, which I usually love at home
for encompassing all my senses, became sense-less in one of the most
sensuous places I've ever been. I also got to experience something
I've claimed to want for years: a Christmas holiday that starts closer
to Christmas than to Thanksgiving (much less Halloween). The holiday
does start too early at home, but I discovered that I don't want it to
start too late either. Savoring the things I enjoy about the holidays
takes time, and the 4-day version didn't ferment enough for me. I'll
also record that this marks my first holiday without eating even a
single Christmas cookie (or any other cookie, for that matter). And I
didn't miss them. Coming from a kid who said "cookie" before "mom" or
"dad", this is a strong indicator of the extent to which India
engrossed me during my visit.
Why Are We Stopping?
27 Dec 2006
Returning home has provided yet another new experience: severe
culture shock. The disorientation I've experienced since being
back has far eclipsed any that I've had when going somewhere
else. Home seems sterile, shallow, and way too quiet. On the
drive back from the airport, the taxi stopped at a red light and
as we sat there I felt an urge to shout about why the *&$ was
he waiting at a light at 1am when nobody else was around. Then
I remembered where I was, or more importantly, where I wasn't;
there were no horns on the roads to ground me.
Obviously, India has left a huge impression, and it will take
several weeks for me to process it all. I loved meeting all the
people and places that Shriram and his folks have so long talked
about. I treasure the insights I've had into him after seeing all of
this. By the time we left, I did see why Bangalore is viewed as
cosmopolitan; it just took time and the experience of visiting other
places to appreciate the visual language of Indian worldliness.
Bangalore has a lot of infrastructural issues to address in the coming
years, but this city is going places.
I have included very few pictures because I didn't take many. The
few times I looked through the lens, I didn't see how to capture what
mattered to me using just a camera. Apologies for those who wanted
the photos to travel vicariously. Shriram did take several, especially
at the temples we visited, so keep an eye on his website for his blog
about the trip. In the meantime, I'm slowly adjusting to life at home
again and brainstorming ways to retain the vitality I saw in India. I
have ho doubt we'll be going back well before another 15 years have
passed.